PianoBuyer

My Other Piano Is a Computer

Introduction to Software Pianos

ALDEN SKINNER

IF THE DIGITAL PIANO is thought of as a complete instrument that’s ready to play right out of the box, piano software can be thought of as part of a “piano kit.” The standard digital piano is completely self-contained in that it’s made up of the memory and processing electronics required to produce the sound, the firmware (software residing on a chip) that is the source of the sound, a keyboard to control the sound, and, more often than not, the audio system needed to hear the sound. If viewed as separate components of a piano kit, however, a personal computer can take on the role of memory and processing, piano software becomes the sound source, a keyboard (very possibly your digital piano) provides control, and powered monitor speakers and/or headphones let you hear your new invention. If you have a digital piano (or an acoustic piano with hybrid features) and a personal computer (Mac or Windows), you already have most of the ingredients of a software-based piano.

The obvious question: If you already have a digital piano, why would you want to add a software piano? Most digital pianos are capable of producing more than one piano sound, but typically, all of these sounds are based on a single piano as a sample source. Think of it this way: If you could add a Bösendorfer, Blüthner, Fazioli, or Steinway to your palette of piano samples for only the cost of the software, would you do it? (I hear the sounds of pianos and computers being pushed together even now.) How about being able to virtually design your own instrument with piano software based on physical modeling? (Physical modeling is the use of mathematical algorithms to mimic the acoustic properties of piano sounds.)

Adding a software piano to your existing piano, or building your own piano from a “piano kit,” is a bit more involved than putting your computer and your piano in the same room — but not by much. Let’s take a look at the requirements on both the computer and piano sides. Since the requirements for the piano are pretty simple, we’ll start there.

Digital and Hybrid Piano Considerations

If your existing piano is going to serve as the basis for your extended piano family, the minimum requirement is that it have MIDI-out capability — USB MIDI makes it slightly easier, but regular MIDI connections will do as well. The good news here is that all currently available digital pianos and most acoustic hybrid pianos already have, or can add, this capability. The next step is to be able to get your existing “host” piano to stop producing its own sound. For digital pianos, this consists of a brief trip to the owner’s manual to learn how to set it up as a “controller” or “master” keyboard. Acoustic pianos must either be capable of “silent” mode or must be converted to enable it (see “Hybrid Pianos” in this issue).

Computer Considerations

Requirements for the computer vary considerably, depending on the piano software used and the choices you make in software settings. Just as with digital pianos, sample-based software is highly dependent on the size of the computer’s memory, while physical modeling software — which creates the sound in real time rather than retrieving an existing sound sample — primarily depends on the speed of the computer’s processor. At a minimum, hardware requirements will involve processor type and speed, and the amount of random-access memory (RAM) and hard-disk space. These requirements range from packages that can run on most recent-vintage mid-range computers, to those requiring higher-speed multi-core processors, 8 Gigabytes (GB) of RAM, over 250 GB of free hard-disk space (preferably on a fast SSD drive), and a dedicated sound card. Either way, you need to check the hardware requirements of the individual software package you’d like to run to make sure it will work properly on your computer — or use it as an excuse to get a new computer.

Aside from making sure that you have enough memory to store and run these packages, processor and sound-card choices will also keep latency in check. Latency is how long it takes the computer to produce a sound from the time you press a key. When latency becomes noticeable, your brain doesn’t know whether to slow your playing so that the sound can catch up, or to speed up to make the sound happen faster. Neither of these works. (Anyone who plays the pipe organ knows what latency is, and will adapt to it without a second thought.)

Software

This is where the real fun starts. There are currently dozens of software-piano packages available, at prices ranging from under $50 to over $500. These include both sample-based packages and packages based on physical modeling. There are products on the market for Mac, PC, and even mobile-device platforms. Several host acoustic pianos (i.e., the sources of the samples) are available via software, including instruments made by Bechstein, Bösendorfer, Blüthner, Fazioli, Kawai, Steingraeber, Steinway, and Yamaha. If you’d like to add some period instruments to your palette, there are also packages with samples from historical fortepianos.

If you’re not particularly into computers, software pianos may not be for you. But if you enjoy even a mild bit of tinkering, and have dreamed of owning a collection of the world’s finest pianos or even of “designing” your own piano, you may find software pianos an irresistible temptation. If you’re interested in following the world of piano software, it’s discussed in Piano World’s “Digital Pianos — Synths & Keyboards” forum.

Leave a Reply

This form is for comments and feedback about our articles. Please do not use it to post ads for pianos for sale or donation. Use our Classified-Ad section instead. For questions about the value of a used piano, see this article, or use our Seller Advisory Service. For other piano-related questions, e-mail us at [email protected]

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 thoughts on “My Other Piano Is a Computer

  1. Good topic!
    I made my own custom piano based on Fazioli, Braunschweig Upright and Walnut Grand, all three by Imperfect Samples.
    Although the samples are amazing, I made some custom adds, specially regarding the machine noises and the full piano resonances.
    While the famous symphatetic resonance is there, it isn’t enough for the full piano effect, specially if you play harder and sustain pedal down, because in an acoustic piano a lot more resonances occur during hard pedalling.
    I called these resonances a funny way as antipathetic resonances, and those are the mess you hear behind the main sounds of the hit cords.
    Long story short, I’ve added a few more sample packs for this purpose, and they are triggered based on the sample system stress, costantly evaluated based on a conjunction of polyphony, pedalling and velocity.
    Well, the result is an insanely realistic acoustic flavoured piano. But I’ve needed a i7 with 16 gb ram computer to really make it playable!!
    Well the result is a so in-the-face piano that zmost people really take a look into the furniture to ensure there isn’t any mechanical parts.
    It’s a pleasure to play it.

    1. Forgot to say that under hard stress, the polyphony easily reachs 2500 notes, that give us an idea of the ridiculously real amount of resonance that occurs in an acoustic piano.
      That’s the hard part for the computer, taking in account that the samples are not looped, but full lenghted.

Sign Up to Receive Announcements of New Articles and Features

I'm a :

Top